GitHub MCP Server vs Smithery
GitHub MCP Server is a developer tool from github (MIT licence, local and remote hosting, 35k GitHub stars, last push 2026-11-21); Smithery is a saaS product from Arcade.dev (Smithery) (AGPL-3.0 licence, 848 GitHub stars, last push 2026-05-31). They share 1 of 2 capabilities and integrations identified for either (overlap 0.60); only GitHub MCP Server covers GitHub. Figures as of 2026-11-21. DER
GitHub MCP Server profileSmithery profileOpen in the compare tool
Side-by-side facts
13 of 16 rows differ (marked). Unknown means no source we track states it.
| Field | GitHub MCP Server | Smithery |
|---|---|---|
| Type · differs | Developer tool · hosted CUR | SaaS product · hosted CUR |
| Publisher · differs | github SRC | Arcade.dev (Smithery) CUR |
| Licence · differs | MIT SRC | AGPL-3.0 CUR |
| Open source · differs | Yes DER | No CUR |
| Pricing model · differs | open-source CUR | freemium CUR |
| Hosting · differs | Remote and local SRC | Unknown |
| Latest version · differs | 2.2.0 SRC | Unknown |
| Languages · differs | go SRC | typescript CUR |
| GitHub stars · differs | 35k (34,637) SRC | 848 (848) SRC |
| Forks · differs | 5.4k SRC | 100 SRC |
| Last push · differs | 2026-11-21 SRC | 2026-05-31 SRC |
| Archived | No SRC | No SRC |
| First published · differs | 2025-09-26 SRC | Unknown |
| Versions recorded · differs | 64 SRC | Unknown |
| Verification | Checked by AgentSidekick against official sources CUR | Checked by AgentSidekick against official sources CUR |
| Last verified | 2026-11-21 CUR | 2026-11-21 CUR |
Shared and unique capabilitiesDER
Capabilities are assigned by keyword rules from each description unless a researcher set them; integrations are services named in the description or package metadata.
Both (1)
Only GitHub MCP Server (1)
Only Smithery (0)
None identified.
Platform compatibility
Status per platform from the evidence we hold. No pairing has been tested by AgentSidekick.
No compatibility evidence
For all 47 platforms on record the status is Unknown or Platform discontinued for both: neither product type implements a standard we can check (MCP, Agent Skills, Claude plugins) and neither publisher names a platform.
Maintenance
Repository activity read from the GitHub API. Activity is not quality.
| Measure | GitHub MCP Server | Smithery |
|---|---|---|
| Status | Active DER | Slowing DER |
| Days since last push | 0 DER | 174 DER |
| Open issues | 232 SRC | 48 SRC |
| Latest GitHub release | v2.2.0 · 2026-11-16 SRC | v1.2.0 · 2026-05-31 SRC |
| Newest registry version | 2.2.0 · 2026-11-16 SRC | Unknown |
Evaluation dimensions
Separate signals with their evidence; there is no overall score. Hover or focus a status for its evidence.
| Dimension | GitHub MCP Server | Smithery |
|---|---|---|
| Source authority | Checked against official sources | Checked against official sources |
| Publisher verification | Organisation account | Organisation account |
| Maintenance activity · differs | Active | Slowing |
| Licence clarity · differs | MIT | AGPL-3.0 |
| Installation clarity · differs | Machine-readable | Unknown |
| Documentation | Repository / website only | Repository / website only |
| Compatibility evidence | Unknown | Unknown |
| Security review | Not reviewed | Not reviewed |
Which fits which requirementDER
Derived from the differences above, one rule per line. Nothing here says either product is better; check the requirement against your own needs.
Choose GitHub MCP Server if…
- you need an integration with GitHub (named for GitHub MCP Server only)
- you require a repository pushed to in the last 90 days (GitHub MCP Server: 2026-11-21; Smithery: 2026-05-31)
- you weigh adoption: 35k vs 848 GitHub stars (popularity, not quality)
- you want machine-readable install metadata (packages or endpoints declared in a registry)
Choose Smithery if…
No measurable difference favours Smithery on licence, hosting, pricing model, coverage, maintenance, adoption or install metadata.
Sources
- GitHub MCP Server · Official MCP Registry: registry.modelcontextprotocol.io (external)checked
- GitHub MCP Server · Curated research: github.com (external)checked
- GitHub MCP Server · Researcher checked: github.com (external)checked
- Smithery · Curated research: smithery.ai (external)checked
- Smithery · Researcher checked: smithery.ai (external)checked
- Smithery · Researcher checked: github.com (external)checked
- Smithery · Researcher checked: arcade.dev (external)checked
Page data last updated .