open-code-review vs gentle-ai
open-code-review is an agent skill from alibaba (Apache-2.0 licence, 55k GitHub stars, last push 2026-11-21); gentle-ai is an agent skill from Gentleman-Programming (MIT licence, 9.4k GitHub stars, last push 2026-11-21). They share 1 of 2 capabilities and integrations identified for either (overlap 0.50); only gentle-ai covers Agent Memory. Figures as of 2026-11-21. DER
open-code-review profilegentle-ai profileOpen in the compare tool
Side-by-side facts
5 of 16 rows differ (marked). Unknown means no source we track states it.
| Field | open-code-review | gentle-ai |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Agent skill · skill-md SRC | Agent skill · skill-md SRC |
| Publisher · differs | alibaba SRC | Gentleman-Programming SRC |
| Licence · differs | Apache-2.0 SRC | MIT SRC |
| Open source | Yes DER | Yes DER |
| Pricing model | Unknown | Unknown |
| Hosting | Unknown | Unknown |
| Latest version | Unknown | Unknown |
| Languages | go SRC | go SRC |
| GitHub stars · differs | 55k (54,922) SRC | 9.4k (9,446) SRC |
| Forks · differs | 4.5k SRC | 904 SRC |
| Last push | 2026-11-21 SRC | 2026-11-21 SRC |
| Archived | No SRC | No SRC |
| First published · differs | 2026-05-18 SRC | 2026-02-27 SRC |
| Versions recorded | Unknown | Unknown |
| Verification | Auto-discovered; type inferred from repository topics HEU | Auto-discovered; type inferred from repository topics HEU |
| Last verified | Unknown | Unknown |
Shared and unique capabilitiesDER
Capabilities are assigned by keyword rules from each description unless a researcher set them; integrations are services named in the description or package metadata.
Both (1)
Only open-code-review (0)
None identified.
Only gentle-ai (1)
Platform compatibility
Status per platform from the evidence we hold. No pairing has been tested by AgentSidekick.
| Platform | open-code-review | gentle-ai |
|---|---|---|
| OpenClaw | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| OpenCode · differs | Protocol-level | Vendor claimed |
| Claude Code · differs | Protocol-level | Vendor claimed |
| Codex · differs | Protocol-level | Vendor claimed |
| Gemini CLI | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| OpenHands | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Warp | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| goose | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Bolt (bolt.new) | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Kiro | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Amp | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Apps in ChatGPT / Apps SDK (now ChatGPT Plugins) | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| ChatGPT | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Claude (claude.ai apps) | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Claude Desktop | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Cursor · differs | Protocol-level | Vendor claimed |
| Devin | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Devin Desktop (formerly Windsurf) | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Factory (Droid) | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Gemini (app) | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| GitHub Copilot | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| GitHub Copilot cloud agent (formerly Copilot coding agent) | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Google Antigravity | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Junie | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Replit Agent | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
| Tabnine | Protocol-level | Protocol-level |
21 other platform(s): Unknown or Platform discontinued for both.
Maintenance
Repository activity read from the GitHub API. Activity is not quality.
| Measure | open-code-review | gentle-ai |
|---|---|---|
| Status | Active DER | Active DER |
| Days since last push | 0 DER | 0 DER |
| Open issues | 139 SRC | 264 SRC |
| Latest GitHub release | v1.14.0 · 2026-11-21 SRC | v4.6.0 · 2026-11-18 SRC |
| Newest registry version | Unknown | Unknown |
Evaluation dimensions
Separate signals with their evidence; there is no overall score. Hover or focus a status for its evidence.
| Dimension | open-code-review | gentle-ai |
|---|---|---|
| Source authority | Auto-discovered | Auto-discovered |
| Publisher verification | Organisation account | Organisation account |
| Maintenance activity | Active | Active |
| Licence clarity · differs | Apache-2.0 | MIT |
| Installation clarity | Unknown | Unknown |
| Documentation | Repository / website only | Repository / website only |
| Compatibility evidence · differs | Protocol-level only | Vendor claimed |
| Security review | Not reviewed | Not reviewed |
Which fits which requirementDER
Derived from the differences above, one rule per line. Nothing here says either product is better; check the requirement against your own needs.
Choose open-code-review if…
- you weigh adoption: 55k vs 9.4k GitHub stars (popularity, not quality)
Choose gentle-ai if…
- you need Agent Memory (classified for gentle-ai only)
- you need a publisher statement naming Claude Code, Cursor, Codex (vendor claim, not tested)
Sources
- open-code-review · GitHub topic search: github.com (external)checked
- open-code-review · SKILL.md files in public GitHub repos: github.com (external)checked
- open-code-review · SKILL.md files in public GitHub repos: github.com (external)checked
- gentle-ai · GitHub topic search: github.com (external)checked
Page data last updated .